Case study

How MyFitnessPal hit their annual goal in January

Peter Chau and his team at MyFitnessPal achieved a 13% lift in subscriptions over control.

Peter Chau
Peter Chau Product Director MyFitnessPal

For competitive reasons, our customers prefer to keep their wins private. However, MyFitnessPal agreed to let us share this case study about our strategic engagement with them (including the test and the win).

The challenge

MyFitnessPal is a top health and fitness app that enables people to track their diet and lifestyle to hit personal fitness goals.

They wanted to increase the conversion rate to premium plans and to increase adoption of annual plans.

The MyFitnessPal plan selection screen as it ran before the test. A yearly plan at $79.99 a year with $239.88 struck through and a 67% savings badge, next to a monthly plan at $19.99 a month, above a start 1-month free trial button.
The upsell as it ran before the test. Open full size

Analysis

The DoWhatWorks research team analyzed our database of over 33,000 experiments to determine what might work for MyFitnessPal.

The team analyzed all components of the upsell experience including how promotional messaging was used to motivate adoption of annual plans.

The analysis revealed that the approach taken on the live experience, using strikethrough pricing, had a strong tendency to lose when tested in their industry. The team recommended an alternative approach to conveying value.

A BetScore dial reading 20 out of 100, labelled strikethrough prices are a weak bet in MyFitnessPal’s sector.
Strikethrough pricing scored a BetScore of 20 in their sector. Open full size

Recommended test

Based on test data, DoWhatWorks recommended that MyFitnessPal test removing the strikethrough pricing and instead include the monthly cost to make it easier to see the savings between the monthly and annual options.

Control and variant side by side. The control keeps the struck through $239.88 and a 67% savings badge. The variant drops both, badges the yearly plan as the best deal, and adds a line reading just $6.67 per month, billed annually.
Control on the left, variant on the right. Open full size

The impact

13%
increase
in conversion rate over control
8%
increase
in annual plans over control

Big wins in January are a big deal to a company like MyFitnessPal. For companies in the fitness space, New Year’s resolution season is their most important time of year (like the holidays are to retailers).

So a big win like this in January carries immediate impact and sets the new baseline for the rest of the year.

Get custom analysis on your website